Sofia Franklyn’s memoir has been out for a matter of days and it has already pulled her old boss into the story.
Barstool Sports founder Dave Portnoy went on The Toast podcast with Claudia and Jackie Oshry on Wednesday to shut down the idea, raised in Franklyn’s book Daddy Issues, that he once hooked up with her former Call Her Daddy co-host Alex Cooper, Page Six reports.
What the book actually says
Franklyn, 34, never states it outright. In the passage at issue, she describes arriving at Portnoy’s apartment for a rooftop meeting with Cooper: “I expect Alex to make a joke about [his apartment], but she’s uncharacteristically awkward and doesn’t say a thing. Something gives me the vibe she’s been here before.”
She then writes that Portnoy made a comment suggesting Cooper knew her way around, which she says confirmed her suspicion.
On The Toast, Portnoy, 49, framed it as Franklyn claiming he “was, like, having sex with Alex.” The Oshry sisters pushed back on that wording. Claudia, 32, explained: “Her reasoning for saying that was when they go to your apartment for a rooftop meeting, she has this sense Alex has been there before.”
Portnoy’s answer
“She had not [been to my apartment before]. She knows that. Like, she knows that! The first time either of them were in my apartment was the rooftop meeting,” Portnoy said.
Asked directly whether he and Cooper ever “kissed or made out,” he answered “No,” adding: “We don’t even like each other.”
Page Six also shared a clip on X in which Portnoy called Franklyn’s recollection of a Barstool holiday party “total fiction.”
He did agree with her on one thing
Portnoy, who repeatedly talked about his “hatred” of Franklyn during the chat, still sided with her on one point: Cooper naming her media company Unwell after a joke Franklyn came up with. “That was stupid by Alex. I don’t know why she did that,” he said. “It is a great name. But I think it was Sofia’s joke.” He added: “That was a misstep by [Cooper], I think.”
The Oshry sisters noted that Portnoy reached out to them for the interview, not the other way round.
Where Alex Cooper stands
Cooper, 32, has not publicly reacted to the memoir and has kept promoting her podcast episodes, Page Six reports. Sources told the outlet she was in “full-on panic mode” over the book’s release. Reps for Cooper and Franklyn did not immediately respond to Page Six. We’ve covered Franklyn’s press tour before, including her awkward Watch What Happens Live moment.
What fans are saying
The Toast clip spread fast. One X account’s upload of Portnoy explaining why he went on the show passed 168,000 views, and Page Six’s own clip of the “total fiction” moment drew more than 44,000 views within hours.
The CGS take
Two things can be true. Franklyn’s passage is a “vibe,” not an accusation, and Portnoy is denying something the book never quite says. But Portnoy choosing to book himself on a rival podcast to talk about it, as the hosts pointed out, tells you how much this book is landing.
It’s the oldest move in a memoir: hint, don’t claim, and let the internet do the rest. Daddy Issues is selling a story fans have wanted since the original Call Her Daddy split, and every denial keeps it in the headlines. The person who could end it is Alex Cooper, and so far she’s saying nothing. Until she does, expect more “vibes” clips, not fewer.
Quick Answers
Did Dave Portnoy hook up with Alex Cooper?
Portnoy denies it. Asked on The Toast whether they ever kissed or made out, he said “No” and “We don’t even like each other.” Cooper hasn’t commented.
What does Sofia Franklyn's book say about Dave Portnoy and Alex Cooper?
In Daddy Issues, Franklyn writes that she got “the vibe” Cooper had been to Portnoy’s apartment before a rooftop meeting. She doesn’t state that they hooked up.
Who named Unwell?
Portnoy said on The Toast that he thinks the name was Sofia Franklyn’s joke and that Alex Cooper using it for her company was “a misstep.”
Sources
- Page Six: Dave Portnoy responds to Sofia Franklyn’s shocking claim he hooked up with Alex Cooper
- Page Six on X: Portnoy calls Franklyn’s holiday party recollection “total fiction”
Read Next
InfluencersMKBHD Cybercab bet: Elon Musk calls him a chicken as Tesla opens orders
InfluencersMrBeast Hunger Games Winner: Kevin Wins $250,000 After Best Friend Drops Weapon
InfluencersSalim the Dream banned from Internet Invitational 2027 by Dave PortnoyGET THE CGS NEWS DROP
The biggest creator, celebrity and money stories, straight to your inbox. Free.
By subscribing you agree to receive emails from The CGS News. Unsubscribe anytime.
